The Enid - Invicta
Jan 1, 2013 15:12:20 GMT
Post by Deleted on Jan 1, 2013 15:12:20 GMT
Enid are a strange group that has been dominated for a very long time by Robert John Godfrey, who started the band up in the 70's.
Their albums are variable but one thing I have felt is Robert's domination for years on the sound.
He has stuck with the same samples/sounds through the years which gave them their unique sound which some love and others hate. Dave (The Amazing Wilf) has coined it - like Marmite, you either love it or hate it. My opinion is that 'marmite' is Robert John Godfrey and always has been for over 30 years.
I have often found his over-romanticised approach a little annoying at times and Robert's vocal attempts have left me feeling underwhelmed.
This latest album is a move away imo from Robert's dominance. About time too, since I feel that their popularity or lack of has been due to his approach.
This album retains some elements of his 'brass band' sounds and the drastic romanticism that he got so hung up with. (Of course, if you know his stuff, that Elgar pomposity as well)
However, it moves away from just Robert's view, at last and the album is imo, one of Enid's better ones. He has found a decent vocalist, Joe Payne, who has a hell of a range and the band just sounds a little different with a hint of Robert still there!! It's less romantic overall and has some nice riff playing and harmonies. The vocalist opens the album with very high falsetto, which he sustains for a long time, but when he actually starts to sing for real, he reveals a real talent and virtuosity that isn't obvious on this album until you try to emulate (as I would) what he's doing.
One thing I like about Enid's sound is the guitar sound that originated in the 70's and has remained. A hint of Robert's old sounds but this new approach to composition is more mature and the long tracks just don't quite seem as long as they used to be. They are less indulgent and more driven with this great vocalist who varies from sounding like the old Focus singer to Freddie Mercury. He's spot on in tuning and the whole album is more vocal/riff led than of old.
If you like an orchestral outlook mixed with progressive rock, this is actually a very good album. (at last) I have been waiting for a long time for Robert's work to mature from that over-indulgent romanticism of the 70's to something a bit more driven and exciting. This album moves the Enid on - thank goodness for that!!!
Robert, if you're reading this - you've matured mate!!! One suggestion - look at your set up and do some updating. Get away from those old sounds you're still using and move on. This is a good start but I still hear the old Robert there with those orchestral samples that you're still using!!
'Heaven's Gate' is the real giveaway. That's what I mean by the RJG domination. Robert, you were doing this 30 years ago. Those brass samples - especially the French horn. The double strings/electric guitar sound, the romantic sweeping melodies that include those angular sweeps. It's all so old hat now and is imo, the low of the album. Your new vocalist is a breath of fresh air but give the new line up space for goodness sake and stop the domination!!!
One last thing - how about warming up the mix? Enid releases have always been 'cool' sounding to me and once again, Robert's own studio influence. Warm the Farm up Robert so that they're not so aggressive sounding on CD!!
Their albums are variable but one thing I have felt is Robert's domination for years on the sound.
He has stuck with the same samples/sounds through the years which gave them their unique sound which some love and others hate. Dave (The Amazing Wilf) has coined it - like Marmite, you either love it or hate it. My opinion is that 'marmite' is Robert John Godfrey and always has been for over 30 years.
I have often found his over-romanticised approach a little annoying at times and Robert's vocal attempts have left me feeling underwhelmed.
This latest album is a move away imo from Robert's dominance. About time too, since I feel that their popularity or lack of has been due to his approach.
This album retains some elements of his 'brass band' sounds and the drastic romanticism that he got so hung up with. (Of course, if you know his stuff, that Elgar pomposity as well)
However, it moves away from just Robert's view, at last and the album is imo, one of Enid's better ones. He has found a decent vocalist, Joe Payne, who has a hell of a range and the band just sounds a little different with a hint of Robert still there!! It's less romantic overall and has some nice riff playing and harmonies. The vocalist opens the album with very high falsetto, which he sustains for a long time, but when he actually starts to sing for real, he reveals a real talent and virtuosity that isn't obvious on this album until you try to emulate (as I would) what he's doing.
One thing I like about Enid's sound is the guitar sound that originated in the 70's and has remained. A hint of Robert's old sounds but this new approach to composition is more mature and the long tracks just don't quite seem as long as they used to be. They are less indulgent and more driven with this great vocalist who varies from sounding like the old Focus singer to Freddie Mercury. He's spot on in tuning and the whole album is more vocal/riff led than of old.
If you like an orchestral outlook mixed with progressive rock, this is actually a very good album. (at last) I have been waiting for a long time for Robert's work to mature from that over-indulgent romanticism of the 70's to something a bit more driven and exciting. This album moves the Enid on - thank goodness for that!!!
Robert, if you're reading this - you've matured mate!!! One suggestion - look at your set up and do some updating. Get away from those old sounds you're still using and move on. This is a good start but I still hear the old Robert there with those orchestral samples that you're still using!!
'Heaven's Gate' is the real giveaway. That's what I mean by the RJG domination. Robert, you were doing this 30 years ago. Those brass samples - especially the French horn. The double strings/electric guitar sound, the romantic sweeping melodies that include those angular sweeps. It's all so old hat now and is imo, the low of the album. Your new vocalist is a breath of fresh air but give the new line up space for goodness sake and stop the domination!!!
One last thing - how about warming up the mix? Enid releases have always been 'cool' sounding to me and once again, Robert's own studio influence. Warm the Farm up Robert so that they're not so aggressive sounding on CD!!